Hi TC. No offence taken, and none given I hope.
It was more a rant at the HandBrake guys for not having done a great deal of homework, as even following their guide produces results far short of what x264 as an encoder is capable of. It's such a shame as the same problem has existed for well over a decade with the MP3 audio standard with most front-end developers totally ignoring the LAME MP3 encoder developer's recommendations when it comes to internal settings, hence MP3 getting a bad name when it's almost impossible for anyone to tell a properly encoded MP3 track from an original CD master, but I digress, as is so often the case.
MediaCoder can be a little overwhelming on first sight, but running other people's profiles under it makes it no harder to use than any other package out there really. It's just a matter of getting the profile in there in the first place which may confuse some, so I'll briefly explain that part now with a quick 'how to' guide for the whole process (a full guide will follow when my holiday with my girlfriend is over and full geekiness resumes
)...
1/ Install MediaCoder.
2/ Optional: Download the latest '8bit-depth' version of x264 from
HERE and place it in the MediaCoder 'codecs' folder. You don't
have to do this, but enhancements and bugfixes come thick and fast with x264, so it seldom hurts and usually helps to keep this up-to-date.
3/ Download my profile from
HERE and save it into the MediaCoder folder or somewhere where you can find it easily.
4/ Run MediaCoder and select 'File, Load Preset'. Navigate to the folder where you saved the profile and load it in.
5/ Now click on 'File, Add File' to load up your unencrypted VOB file. Note: You can load multiple files here but it won't always join them properly, so it's better to join multiple parts of the same movie with a VOB joiner (
Link) before loading it as one large file ideally.
6/ Click on the 'Start' button. If you'd like to determine an output path for the encoded movie, set one in the 'Output Folder' box at top-right
before hitting 'Start'.
Encoding will take many hours to complete. I'm looking at around 5 hours for every hour of source material here on a 4GHz dual-core Intel Core2Duo CPU, so expect to leave it running overnight or all day for each movie. Your PC should still remain perfectly stable and fully usable for other tasks whilst encoding (unless it's faulty in some way), although encoding will naturally take longer if the machine is kept very busy by other tasks.
There are quicker methods for encoding to x264, but the quality won't even come close to allowing the encoder to make the kind of decisions this profile allows it to make at encode time. It really is worth the wait if quality matters to you. You're unlikely to find any other method that matches this for quality at the same file size of roughly 10MB for every minute of source material.
I'll be back with a full guide in a week or so but I can answer brief questions here in the meantime, so please ask if you need any further help or would like to know in which ways this differs technically from a typical HandBrake encoding. Have fun!
Cheers, Slipstreem.